I saw Wall-E today at the Disney Studios at a special screening. Some observations:
- This was a “perfect” movie. And that is not a term I use lightly. I deem perfect movies one’s whom I can’t find a single fault with. One who’s every frame is necessary, perfect and flawless. From soundtrack, diegetic and non-diegetic sound, dialog (or lack there of), mise-en-scene, color, focus…etc. The only other movies I really bestow this to currently include Rushmore, Shawshank Redemption, Godfather, Finding Nemo, Germany Year Zero, Bicycle Thief, 400 Blows and a few others.
- The soundtrack was amazing, a striking blend between sardonic self-referential humor, amazingly moving themes and perfect tonal variations. However, not as moving on first listen as Finding Nemo was.
- The beginning 40 minutes will be studied by film students of the future as an example of how restraint can lead to drama, tragedy and comedy in turn, often at the same time.
- It is not a movie for kids. This was hard sci-fi, dark and frankly quite disturbing in parts. Its not like Nemo’s faux death at the end during the “swim down” sequence. This was severe Christ-allegory mixed with a near dire satirical take on humanity.
- This was the first Pixar film where I wasn’t taken out of myself thinking “I wonder what kind of shader they used?” or “the timing there is perfect.” This wasn’t animation, it was almost super-reality.
- Seeing a movie done by Disney and screened by Disney is fantastic. No commercials. No trailers. A flawless digital projection with the most perfect sound I’ve ever had at a theater. This was in the main theater at the 500 S. Buena Vista studio (the very first).
- How is it one of the most affecting love stories I’ve ever seen was between two robots with no dialog? Seriously, a metaphorical/figurative spark? And it works?
- I think Andrew Stanton and Brad Bird are the heir apparents to Ollie and Frank.
- A hell of a lot attention was given to motivation to technology, even when suspension of disbelief was needed for its use (ie, scale in space-flight)
- After the movie Amy and I were walking in downtown Burbank and saw a woman, overweight, in a wheel chair, shuffling her feet to move it (ie, she really didn’t need it), drinking an extra large Coke from 7-11. It was quite unnerving.
- If anyone calls this a “cartoon” or a “kids movie” I’m going to smack them in the head. It is a Film.
See this movie, as it is film history in the making.
Comments 4
I felt exactly the same way. I was so stunned by this film that the prospect of me watching a DVD tonight was just so dull. I will definitely have to give this film another viewing (or three) before it leaves theaters.
I also feel the same about it being a film. As I was walking out, I was thinking that I hope they enter it for Best Picture next year rather than Best Animated Film.
Posted 28 Jun 2008 at 11:25 pm ¶I saw this last night, and was blown away. Good to see I’m not alone in that. And Daniel: I’m hoping it gets Best Picture as well.
Posted 29 Jun 2008 at 7:06 am ¶i loved it, but dont you think the third act was a little rushed? I mean, the big drama was not getting to push a button to get the plant in and then suddenly they’re home and there’s fields of different kinds of plants? How did they get varieties? How did the whole civilization learn how to farm? etc…
still, the animation is as real as actual reality, even if the politics were pretty heavy handed.
also not sure how i felt about having live action intermingled, since it kind of drew attention to the CGI aspect of the character models as compared to Fred Willard.
All in all, shares a spot with Nemo and Ratatouillie as my fave Pixar.
Also, you missed (at least in my theater) another movie about a rodent in france who learns to cook, coming from Universal this holiday season.
Good times.
Posted 04 Jul 2008 at 8:16 am ¶Ethan,
I too look at Wall-E as a movie, a film definitely not a cartoon. I posted some thoughts about the movie’s philosophical content too.
http://www.pampelmoose.com/mspeaks/2008/07/wall-e-a-parable-for-our-eventual-extinction
Dave Allen
Posted 08 Jul 2008 at 2:46 pm ¶Post a Comment